Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Two Buyers for One Stand of Pine: White v. King (1888–1891)

Published · 1 cited source

County: Otsego County

Scope and source

This entry rests on a single source: the Michigan Supreme Court's opinion in White v. King, decided July 28, 1891 [1, p. 108]. The opinion reproduces two letters and a receipt, and summarizes testimony from a trial that ended in a directed verdict. The letters are known here only as the court printed them. At trial, the defendant's counsel objected that they were "not shown to be the letters of Mr. La Salle" [1, p. 110]. The court did not decide who was entitled to the timber. It sent the case back for a new trial, and the outcome of any retrial is not known from this source.

The land and the letters

The case concerned saw logs cut from 40 acres in the county of Otsego [1, p. 108]. The opinion says the land was owned by "Edward S. La Sallé, of Portland, Mich." [1, p. 108]. The letters reproduced in the opinion are signed "E. L. La Salle" [1, p. 109]. The opinion does not explain the difference in initials.

On May 19, 1888, according to the first letter, La Salle wrote from Portland to Cooper & Crane at Gaylord. He wrote that he had "several chances to sell a piece of land I have in Bagley township, or to sell the pine on it" [1, p. 108]. He asked them to look it over and see what the pine was worth, adding, "I think I will let you sell it." He mentioned that Robert King of Lapeer, "who has a shingle-mill in or near Gaylord," had written wanting to buy the land and had recently come to Portland to see him [1, p. 108]. The letter gives the parcel as the southwest quarter of the northwest quarter of section 11, town 30 north, range 3 west [1, p. 109].

A second letter, dated May 28, 1888, and addressed to A. A. Crane at Gaylord, answered a letter of the 24th. "I did not suppose the pine was in so bad a condition," it said. "You may sell the pine if you can. I have written to King that I would leave it to you" [1, p. 109].

Two sales

According to the opinion, Crane sold the pine to Carrie E. White on July 11, 1888, for $115. She paid $15 down and the $100 balance on August 11 [1, p. 109]. The receipt, as reproduced, begins "Received of Mrs. John White $100, balance due for pine timber". Its printed signature block reads "E. L. La Salle. Per A. A. Crane, Agent" [1, p. 109].

White entered the land about July 11 under what the opinion calls "a parol license" from Crane as La Salle's agent, and cut the timber into saw logs. The cutting was finished September 1, 1888 [1, p. 109]. On October 17, King notified her that he claimed the timber and forbade her to remove the logs. The court said this was the first she knew of any competing claim. Soon afterward King removed the logs over her protest, and she sued to recover them [1, p. 109].

King's position was that he had bought the timber from La Salle himself on June 28, 1888. He put in evidence a copy of a bill of sale of that date, giving him two years to enter and take the timber [1, pp. 109–110].

King also testified about his own dealings, as the court summarized them. He said that when he visited La Salle at Portland, La Salle said he would write to Crane and have him place a price on the timber, and that King "perhaps could make a deal with him for the timber" [1, p. 110]. About a month later, King testified, he tried and failed to buy from Crane. He then wrote La Salle that Crane "was not doing the fair thing," and offered to take the timber at what it was worth. La Salle replied asking whether Crane would not make King a price [1, pp. 110–111].

The ruling

The trial judge, in Otsego circuit court, found no evidence for the jury that Crane had authority to sell, and directed a verdict for King [1, pp. 108, 110]. The Supreme Court held that this was error. With King's testimony "supplementing the letters," White was entitled to go to the jury on Crane's authority. Neither Crane nor White, the court noted, had heard anything contradicting the letters until King's notice of October 17 [1, p. 111]. If La Salle sold to King on June 28, the court said, "he did so without revoking the agency of Crane, and without the knowledge of Crane or the plaintiff" [1, p. 111].

The court also explained why King's bill of sale of the timber did not, without notice, revoke White's license in this case. In this case, it said, King had only a bill of sale of the timber, "which was no more than a license." Until White received notice of it, it could not revoke her license [1, p. 111]. Whether she could recover still depended on whether Crane was authorized to sell, a question for a jury. The judgment was reversed and a new trial granted [1, pp. 111–112].

What remains unknown

The opinion does not show the original letters, the June 28 bill of sale, or the trial testimony in full. It does not say whether a retrial occurred or what its outcome was, or who finally kept the logs or the money. The report lists an "A. A. Crane" as counsel for White; the opinion does not say whether he is the same Crane [1, p. 108].

Single source: this entry rests on one court opinion. The letters and receipt are known only as the court printed them, and the court did not decide who was entitled to the timber.

Sources

  1. Carrie E. White v. Robert King, 87 Mich. 107 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Morse, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 87, pp. 107–112, William D. Fuller, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1891; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, argued June 30 and July 1, decided July 28, 1891). Printed pp. 107–112 used (PDF pages 159–164 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.