Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Which Maples Can Be Tapped? What Extension Sources Say About Michigan's Sugaring Trees

Published · 4 cited sources

Region-wide entry, not about a single county. Browse by county

Scope

This entry compares what four university extension publications say about which maple species can be tapped for syrup and how they differ. Two are Michigan State University (MSU) Extension articles from 2012 and 2013; the others are a 2024 Ohio State University fact sheet and a University of Minnesota Extension page reviewed in 2024. The Ohio and Minnesota sources describe trees in their own states, not Michigan specifically. This is a reference summary, not a guide to tapping or to making food.

The preferred trees: sugar and black maple

All four sources put sugar maple first. MSU Extension calls the sugar maple and "its cousin, the black maple" the best trees to tap, because they often produce the sweetest sap [1][2]. Ohio State agrees that sugar and black maple are preferred because their sap has a higher sugar content than other maples, and says black maple's sap is similar to sugar maple's [3]. Minnesota's page says commercial producers generally prefer sugar maple, or hard maple, for the sweetest sap [4].

The sources give slightly different figures for that sweetness. MSU puts sugar maple sap at about 2 to 2.5 percent sugar on average [1]. Ohio State says sugar maple sap "can run 2% or higher" [3]. Minnesota gives an average of 2 percent for sap in general [4]. All three connect the familiar ratio of about 43 gallons of sap per gallon of syrup to sap at roughly that concentration [1][3][4]. Ohio State and Minnesota both note that lower-sugar sap needs more gallons, and Ohio State adds that it takes more fuel and time to boil [3][4].

Red and silver maple

Red and silver maples can also be tapped, the sources agree, with drawbacks. MSU says their sap is usually less sweet and produces more "sugar sand" during boiling [1][2]. Ohio State puts red maple sap at usually 1.5 to 2 percent sugar, so it takes more sap, fuel and time per gallon of syrup [3]. It says silver maple, like red, can be one of the first trees to bud in spring, which shortens its season. It adds that good syrup can be made from either, though it is more likely to be cloudy [3]. Minnesota lists red and silver maple among the four species that can be used for sap there [4].

Boxelder

Ohio State notes that boxelder is technically a maple, a member of the maple genus, though its leaves are compound [3]. MSU's articles do not discuss it. Minnesota counts it among its four usable species [4]. Ohio State says boxelder syrup can have a heavy, almost sorghum-like flavor that some find bitter, and that its sap "should not normally be combined" with sap from other maples. Ohio State also notes that good boxelder syrup is quite palatable and is produced where other maples are scarce [3].

Norway maple: the sources disagree

Norway maple is a non-native landscape tree that Ohio State says is considered invasive in some states [3]. On tapping it, the sources conflict. MSU's 2012 and 2013 articles say it is the only maple that should not be tapped, because its sap is milky rather than clear [1][2]. Ohio State's 2024 fact sheet says that all of the maples it lists, including Norway maple, "can be used to produce syrup." It reports that many people find Norway maple sap similar in sugar content to sugar and black maple [3]. For identification, Ohio State notes that a Norway maple leaf exudes milky sap from the base of its stalk when it is removed from the twig [3]. This entry does not try to settle the difference. Anyone weighing it should consult current extension guidance.

Telling a maple from other trees

Ohio State warns that many hobbyists have tapped an oak or hickory by mistake. It points out that maples have opposite branching, with leaves and buds attached in opposite pairs, and suggests identifying trees while the leaves are still on [3]. Its identification notes give each species' leaf form and typical site: sugar maple on moist but well-drained uplands, red maple from bottomland to upland, and silver maple and boxelder on bottomland or wet sites [3].

Tree size: differing guidelines

The sources also publish different size rules, which is a reminder that guidance changes. MSU's 2012 article says trees should be at least 10 inches in diameter at 4.5 feet. It says trees of 10 to 15 inches can support one taphole and trees of 16 to 20 inches can support two, and notes that many forest health experts suggest two taps per tree as an optimum [2]. Ohio State cites newer guidelines from the University of Vermont's Proctor research center: one tap for trees 10 to 12 inches in diameter, two for trees over 24 inches, and no more than two per tree, with lower rates for trees in poorer health [3]. Minnesota calls for at least 10 inches at 4 feet, and no more than two taps in any tree over 20 inches [4]. These are summarized here for comparison, not as instructions.

Sources

  1. Kidd, Russell. “Why are maple trees tapped to make maple syrup?.” Michigan State University Extension, March 14, 2013. Original article · Archived copy ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
  2. Kidd, Russell. “Making maple syrup in your own backyard: Part 1.” Michigan State University Extension, March 7, 2012. Original article · Archived copy ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
  3. Ober, Les, and Kathy Smith (revisers); original author Randall B. Heiligmann. “Hobby maple syrup production (fact sheet F-36).” Ohio State University Extension, March 20, 2024. Fact sheet · No archived copy found ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14
  4. “Homemade maple syrup.” University of Minnesota Extension, reviewed 2024. Extension page · No archived copy found ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.