Sturgeon Point's Season, 1880-81: The Marine City Fire and Three Other Calls
Scope
This entry reports what one government publication says about a single life-saving station over one year. The publication is the United States Life-Saving Service's annual report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1881 [1, PDF p. 7]. In it the station appears as "Station No. 5, Tenth District, (Sturgeon Point, Lake Huron,)" [1, p. 98]. The report's account of services for the year opens with an entry dated "July 3, 1880" [1, p. 97]. Its July-December entries therefore fall in 1880; the year is not printed beside them. It records four services by this station and does not name the keeper or the surfmen, and they are not named here.
The report does not say which county the station stood in. It does place the Marine City fire "off Alcona" [1, p. 106]. An 1881 state gazetteer describes Alcona as a village that "Lies on the shore of Lake Huron in the township and county of Alcona, 9 miles north of Harrisville, the county seat" [2, p. 130]. The county link in this entry rests on those two statements.
July 12, 1880: cattle adrift
At 3 p.m. the station crew saw something floating about two miles out. They rowed to it and found "a steamer's gangway-slip, with two head of cattle fastened to it, one of the animals being still alive." The animals had been lost overboard from the steamer St. Paul. The crew towed them ashore and turned them over to the owners [1, p. 98].
August 29, 1880: the Marine City
The report's whole account is one paragraph. The side-wheel steamer Marine City, of Port Huron, was bound to Toledo with lumber and fish. She carried "one hundred and ten passengers and a crew of forty-eight men." She "took fire at half-past 3 o'clock in the afternoon, off Alcona, about two miles from land, and was destroyed." The report continues: "Although not within the scope of the Service, a portion of the crew" rowed out in the surf-boat "and picked up five persons, tugs and other boats having rescued all of the others saved. Nine persons were lost" [1, p. 106].
The report gives no cause for the fire and does not name the dead. A later vessel record compiled by Bowling Green State University's Historical Collections of the Great Lakes dates the loss "August 28, 1880." It places it "off Sturgeon Point, two miles from Alcona" and also gives nine lives lost [3]. That record gives only "HCGL", the collection itself, as its source. The report is the contemporary account; this entry does not settle the difference.
November 6, 1880: the John Kelderhouse
The schooner John Kelderhouse, of Sheboygan, was carrying corn from Chicago to Buffalo. She met "a snow-storm so thick as to obscure the light at Sturgeon Point" and ran onto the south reef of Black River Island, "nine miles north" of the station. The keeper saw her, procured a sail-boat and went out. The crew then helped lighten her until she could be pulled off [1, p. 128].
May 11-17, 1881: the Metropolis
The side-wheel steamer Metropolis, of Bay City, stranded in fog near Black River Island. The report puts the spot "eleven miles north" of the station. A passenger "who had been put ashore at Alcona" brought word to the station's patrol. The crew made several trips out. On May 16 their wagon broke down. After "two hours' hard rowing they reached Alcona," procured another team and wagon, and launched again at Black River. The report closes: "The vessel was got off" [1, pp. 187-188].
One annual report and one gazetteer entry. The report names no keeper or surfmen, gives no fire cause and names no victims; the station's own county is not stated in these sources.
Sources
- “Annual Report of the Operations of the United States Life-Saving Service for the Fiscal Year Ending June 30, 1881.” United States Life-Saving Service; Washington: Government Printing Office, 1881; Internet Archive item lifesavingservic03unitrich, 1881. Printed pp. 97, 98, 106, 128 and 187–188 used; printed page = PDF page − 6 in the services section. Internet Archive copy (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8
- “Michigan State Gazetteer and Business Directory, vol. 1.” Detroit: R. L. Polk & Co.; Internet Archive item michiganstategaz01unse_1, 1881. Page 130, “Alcona,” used. Internet Archive item · Archive status not checked ↩
- “MARINE CITY (official no. 16447), vessel record.” Bowling Green State University Libraries, Historical Collections of the Great Lakes, undated online database record. Database record · Archive status not checked ↩
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.