Choosing Farms for New Uses: The Port Oneida Decision of 2008
Scope and sources
This entry follows one planning decision by the National Park Service at Port Oneida, in Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, between 2005 and 2008. Its sources all come from one place, the National Park Service itself:
- the signed Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) with its errata [1];
- the agency's written response to public comments [2];
- a park news release [3].
The NPS catalog record for the Port Oneida Rural Historic District lists it in Leelanau County [4]. The full environmental assessment, its underlying studies, and the original comment letters were not read for this entry. The release's quoted words come from the HTML text of the NPS page, not from a page image. Public comments are known here only through the agency's response table, not the original letters. Quotations from comments reproduce that table's wording, not wording independently checked against the letters. These documents record plans and a decision. They do not show whether the planned work was funded or built, and nothing here describes Port Oneida today.
The district and the problem
The FONSI describes Port Oneida as 19 farms, 14 of them owned by the Park Service, on more than 3,400 acres. It calls the district "the largest intact agricultural district in the National Park System" [1, p. 1]. It reports that about 35 of the district's 110 historic structures were in poor to fair condition and needed immediate work. It adds that Port Oneida had no public restrooms, visitor contact station or adequate parking [1, pp. 1–2]. Three objectives guided the project: stabilize selected structures and landscapes, provide a visitor contact station, and "[p]rovide employee housing within Port Oneida" [1, p. 2].
Asking the public
The FONSI and the news release give the same sequence of consultation [1, pp. 9–10; 3]:
- August 2005: a booth at the Port Oneida Fair, and scoping letters to agencies, tribes, organizations and citizens.
- April 11 to May 8, 2006: preliminary comments, with a workshop at the Port Oneida Schoolhouse on May 3.
- September 17 to October 19, 2007: public review of the environmental assessment, with an open house in Empire on October 3.
According to the FONSI, twenty-three comments came from the general public. One partner group, Preserve Historic Sleeping Bear, sent a letter [1, p. 10].
Five alternatives, and a change
The FONSI describes five alternatives: no action and four action alternatives. Each of the four action alternatives paired a farm for a visitor contact station with a farm for staff housing [1, pp. 4–5]. Alternative 5 was both the environmentally preferable and the agency's preferred alternative. It placed the visitor station at the Kelderhouse farm and staff housing at the Carsten Burfiend farm [1, p. 2].
After the comment period, the team kept the Kelderhouse choice but moved the housing. The FONSI explains that the additional parking and beach access planned at the Carsten Burfiend farm "would create a lack privacy for the employees" [1, p. 2]. Housing was therefore assigned to the Goffar farm, a four-bedroom, two-bath house of 2,100 square feet. The FONSI noted the house was under a reservation of use and occupancy due to expire in 2011 [1, pp. 2–3]. The news release gave a different summary of the reason: the Goffar farm was chosen "[b]ecause of its size, condition, and location" [3]. The documents do not say whether the reservation's expiry affected the timing of any work.
Disagreement on the record
The agency's response to comments, dated September 15, 2008, records objections and the agency's replies. As presented in that table, commenters said [2, pp. 1–2, 4]:
- the plan offered little more than parking, trails and restrooms;
- the comment period should be extended by two months;
- the criteria and point values used to choose sites were "ill conceived";
- planning should have come within an overall plan for Port Oneida;
- the project should consider small-scale farming.
The agency answered that agricultural activity was outside the scope of the assessment [2, p. 1]. It noted that the National Environmental Policy Act requires a 30-day public review for environmental assessments [2, p. 2]. One comment urged the Carsten Burfiend farm for a hostel proposed by Hostelling International. The agency replied that an adaptive use serving park visitors or mission "would take precedence over use by a potential partner" not needed to serve the public [2, p. 5]. The FONSI itself reported that no "highly controversial effects" had been identified during the assessment or the public review [1, p. 8].
The errata corrected one historical point raised in review: the Kelderhouse farm "was built by William Kelderhouse, not his father, Thomas" [1, Errata].
The decision and its limits
The FONSI was recommended by Superintendent Dusty Shultz and approved by Midwest Regional Director Ernest Quintana [1, p. 10]. Their handwritten dates on the signature page read 6/24/2008 and 6-30-2008. The news release of September 23, 2008, says the FONSI was signed June 30, 2008 [3]. The release also described the plans as future work: "Once funds can be secured, the Kelderhouse farm will be rehabilitated as a visitor contact station" [3]. Which structures to stabilize was left to be "determined based on need at the time of project funding" [1, p. 3].
Single agency: all sources come from the National Park Service. They record plans and a decision, not whether any work was funded or built, and public comments are known only through the agency's response table.
Sources
- “Port Oneida Rural Historic District Finding of No Significant Impact, with Errata.” National Park Service, Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore; hosted on the National Park Service planning website (planning.nps.gov), recommended June 24, 2008 and approved June 30, 2008 (handwritten signature-page dates, not a publication date); errata dated June 2008. FONSI printed pp. 1–10 and the errata used (PDF pages 3–13); page numbers cited are the FONSI's printed pages. FONSI (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14
- “Port Oneida Rural Historic District Environmental Assessment: Response to Public Comments.” National Park Service; hosted on the National Park Service planning website (planning.nps.gov), dated September 15, 2008. Pages 1–2, 4 and 5 used. Comments are known only through this agency table. Response (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
- “Port Oneida Rural Historic District Environmental Assessment Completed.” National Park Service, Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, news release, release dated September 23, 2008. Quoted from the page's HTML text, not a page image. News release · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
- “Port Oneida Rural Historic District (NRIS 97000563).” National Park Service, NPGallery catalog record, undated. Used only for the county (Leelanau). NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.