Beer in the Back Room: People v. Bedell, Kalkaska County, 1909–1910
Scope and sources
This entry rests on one source: the Michigan Supreme Court's reported decision in People v. Bedell, 162 Mich. 230–237 (1910). The decision includes the headnotes, the majority opinion by Justice Moore, the testimony it reproduces, and a concurrence by Justice Ostrander. These parts are not independent of one another. The testimony appears only as the court chose to reproduce it, and the opinion itself says there was "much other testimony of a like character" that it did not print [p. 234]. The full trial record, the local-option election and the statute text were not read for this entry. The decision does not record any sentence. It also says nothing about what happened to Frank Bedell afterward.
The charge
According to the information quoted by Justice Moore, Frank Bedell was charged with this: on September 14, 1909, at the town of Boardman, "in the county of Kalkaska," he gave and furnished beer to Judd Richardson. The information said this was contrary to the local-option law in force in the county [pp. 230–231]. The trial court's charge placed the events at the village of South Boardman [p. 232]. A jury convicted Bedell. He brought the case to the Supreme Court "on exceptions before sentence" [p. 231]. The procedural headnote says "Exceptions before judgment," while Moore's opinion says "exceptions before sentence" [pp. 230–231]. The court recorded that he offered no evidence of his own [p. 231].
What Richardson testified
Richardson, a witness for the prosecution, testified as follows [pp. 233–234]:
- Bedell ran a barber shop in South Boardman, on the business street where the post office was.
- On the afternoon of September 14, about three o'clock, Richardson followed Bedell from the shop through one room and into a smaller back room. He called that room Bedell's "private room, in which there was a bed".
- Two men, William Taylor and George Burdick, were already there.
- Richardson said he drank from a bottle of whisky and from a beer bottle on the floor, near a can holding ice.
- He did not see Bedell drink. Bedell said nothing to him about drinking and passed in and out of the room while working in the shop.
- He said: "No one invited me in there in the first place."
- He did not know where the liquor came from at the time. Only after leaving the shop did he hear that Burdick had brought it.
The cross-examination gave the shop's orientation two ways. It said the shop "faces west," and in the same passage that "The shop door faces the east" [p. 234]. The record does not reconcile them.
The disputed argument
In his closing argument, the prosecutor told the jury that the men "met there often" and that it was "their rendezvous" [p. 231]. Defense counsel objected that this was not a charge of keeping a place where liquor was furnished. He also objected that testimony about the evening of September 14 had been stricken from the record. At the defense's request, the judge charged the jury to treat that testimony "as never having been given" [p. 232]. The Supreme Court held that what occurred on this point "is not reversible error" [p. 232]. The stricken evening testimony is not reproduced, and this entry does not describe it.
The law as charged
The trial judge told the jurors that it would violate the local-option law then in force in the county if, beyond a reasonable doubt, they found that Bedell had procured beer and placed it on ice in his bedroom where it was accessible; that several men, including Richardson, came there with his knowledge and consent; and that he "knowingly allowed and permitted" Richardson to drink that beer [p. 232]. The defense argued that Bedell was acting "in the exercise of an act of hospitality." It relied on an earlier case, People v. Peterson [p. 232].
The majority
Justice Moore held that Peterson was "easily distinguishable" [pp. 234–235]. He concluded that the record did not show "a justifiable act of hospitality." Instead, he wrote, it showed "what is vulgarly known as a 'blind pig.'" [p. 236]. These are the court's characterizations. The opinion does not describe any sale, price or payment. The court wrote: "The exceptions are overruled, and the case is remanded for further proceedings according to law" [p. 236]. Justices Hooker, Blair and Stone concurred [p. 236]. The reporter's syllabus line reads "Affirmed" [p. 230]. The body of the opinion describes review before sentence and a remand.
The concurrence
Justice Ostrander agreed that the conviction could be sustained. In his summary of the testimony, which he called undisputed, someone purchased "nine pint bottles of beer" in another village at Bedell's request, along with two bottles of whisky for himself. That person took the liquor to Bedell's sleeping room [p. 236]. Ostrander described Bedell as a single man who boarded at a restaurant and lived in rooms behind his shop [p. 236].
He then added a qualification: "the rooms occupied by an unmarried man may be considered to be his home." In such a home, he wrote, a man could "in a proper manner" host friends [p. 236]. If the testimony had been less conclusive, he would have regarded the jury charge as faulty. In that case, he wrote, it should have put to the jury whether Bedell was "exercising a decent hospitality" [p. 237]. He did not dissent from the result.
Where the record ends
The decision was submitted April 22, 1910, and decided July 14, 1910 [p. 230]. It ends with the remand. No sentence or later outcome appears in it.
Single source: this entry rests on one reported decision. Its testimony appears only as the court chose to reproduce it, and the decision records no sentence or later outcome.
Sources
- People v. Bedell, 162 Mich. 230 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Moore, J., concurrence of Ostrander, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 162, pp. 230–237, James M. Reasoner, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1911 (title-page imprint); official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, submitted April 22, decided July 14, 1910). Printed pp. 230–237 used (PDF pages 258–265 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.