Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

A Life Boat on a $475 Bond: The North Manitou Island Life-Saving Station

Published · 1 cited source

County: Leelanau County

Scope

This entry rests on one source: the National Historic Landmark nomination for the North Manitou Island Lifesaving Station (other name: North Manitou Coast Guard Station), NRIS 98001191. William Herd, park ranger, and Kimberly Mann, historic architect, both of Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, prepared it on January 26, 1994. It was edited by Candace Clifford and Patricia Henry of the National Park Service, and this copy is stamped "National Historic Landmarks Survey February 13, 2004" [1, p. 32]. The certification blocks are blank. NPGallery gives a publication date of August 5, 1998. This entry describes the station as documented in the 1994 nomination and does not assert a landmark designation date. Everything below is the nomination's account. Letters, annual reports and the 1984 historic-resource study it cites were not read. Where the form disagrees with itself, both versions are given.

The volunteer boat, 1854

The station is a federally owned district of 12 contributing resources (6 buildings, 1 site and 5 structures) and 1 noncontributing building, in Leelanau County [1, p. 1].

In 1854, the nomination says, an appropriation of $12,500 bought forty-seven lifeboats, "nearly half" of them for Lake Michigan [1, p. 6]. Where no federal official was present, two or more persons could post a "$475 bond" and receive a boat. Page 20 repeats the total of forty-seven but breaks it down as 16 for Lake Erie, nine for Lake Ontario, 25 for Lake Michigan and one for Lake Superior, which adds to 51 [1, p. 20]. The nomination does not reconcile the two.

Letters dated September 15, 1854, the nomination says, acknowledge "$475 in bond signed by Nicholas Pickard, and others, for a Life Boat ... at North Manitou Island." Secretary Guthrie ordered a Francis Metallic boat from Brooklyn. Pickard "owned the cordwood station" and apparently received boathouse plans [1, p. 6]; [1, pp. 20-21]. The letters are cited to National Archives Record Group 26; they were not seen for this entry.

The surviving Volunteer Rescue Station is about 17 feet by 36 feet and sided in cedar boards. The nomination calls it "the only boathouse built from these specifications still in existence" and the only Great Lakes building of the volunteer system [1, p. 6]; [1, p. 21]. That attribution rests on letters from four historians (note 3 on page 6). "No records of rescues" exist for the 1854 Great Lakes boats, because "no reports were required" [1, p. 21].

A Life-Saving Service station

After the act of June 20, 1874, a tract 40 by 20 feet was leased from Pickard for one dollar a year [1, p. 6]; [1, p. 23]. Of 12 Lake Michigan stations built in 1876, nine were Life Boat Stations. North Manitou's was built in 1877 and went into operation the next year, with Daniel L. Buss as keeper, an appointment the nomination cites to a 1991 work by Rusco. From 1878 it had a paid six-man crew [1, p. 24].

The Life Boat Station used a modified plan by Francis W. Chandler. The nomination dates his drawings to the "winter of 1875" and also describes "a design by Francis W. Chandler in 1876"; one page calls him "Frank Chandler" [1, p. 8]; [1, p. 23]. The building had a clipped gable and a lookout balcony. A separate dwelling, "believed" designed by Albert B. Bibb, was built in 1887. The flagpole was replaced about 1905 with a 70-foot steel tower, and a supply building present by 1895 had become a "ready room" by 1902 [1, p. 8]; [1, p. 23]; [1, p. 25].

Married surfmen built private cottages near stations. The house of Hans Halseth, a surfman from the mid-1890s to at least the late 1920s, survives; it was moved about 1910 [1, p. 26].

The boats changed over the years: first a Merryman self-bailing, self-righting lifeboat, 26 feet 8 inches by 7 feet 3 inches, drawing 1 foot 9 inches; then a Long Branch surfboat (1884), a 30-foot Mackinaw boat (1885), a Long Branch (1894), a 26-foot Beebe-McLellan (1895) and a new lifeboat (1896). The water was too shallow for 34-foot lifeboats or 36-foot motor lifeboats [1, pp. 26-27].

"Saved 772," and closure

In the Life-Saving Service years, the nomination says, the station "saved 772 individuals from shipwrecks with no shipwreck victim losing their life" [1, p. 27]. The figure is cited to Jim Muhn's 1984 National Park Service Historic Resource Study, page 66, which was not read for this entry. It is the nomination's tally, not a count taken from the annual reports. The crew also gave fire, first-aid and police service to islanders [1, p. 27].

The station joined the Coast Guard in 1915. A late-1920s review by Lt. Willard Smith found it no longer needed, since it lacked a protected harbor [1, p. 27]. The period of significance is 1854-1932, 1932 being the last year with a full-time crew. The station was found obsolete in 1933 and left with a skeleton crew of two until about 1938, when it was closed and sold to the Manitou Island Association [1, p. 15]; [1, p. 28]. Two pages say it was sold about 1938; another says the Association purchased it "in the 1940s" [1, p. 8]; [1, p. 28]; [1, p. 24]. The National Park Service bought the island in 1984 [1, p. 28].

Single 1994 nomination; certification blank; 772 from a 1984 study; no designation date asserted

Sources

  1. Herd, William, and Kimberly Mann. “North Manitou Island Lifesaving Station (other name: North Manitou Coast Guard Station), National Historic Landmark nomination.” National Park Service; prepared by William Herd and Kimberly Mann, edited by Candace Clifford and Patricia Henry; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (NRIS 98001191), prepared January 26, 1994; NPGallery publication date August 5, 1998; certification blocks on this copy are blank. Page references are the form page numbers, which match the PDF pages. Nomination (PDF) · NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24 ↩25 ↩26 ↩27 ↩28

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.