Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

The JOSEPH S. FAY at Forty Mile Point, 19 October 1905

Published · 1 cited source

County: Presque Isle County

Scope

This entry rests on one source: the National Register of Historic Places registration form for the JOSEPH S. FAY Shipwreck Site (site number 20UH088; final reference RS100001838), near Rogers City in Presque Isle County. Philip A. Hartmeyer, maritime archaeologist at Thunder Bay National Marine Sanctuary, prepared it on January 11, 2017 [1, PDF p. 25]. The State Historic Preservation Office signed it on December 21, 2017, the National Register received it on January 24, 2018, and the National Park Service accepted it on February 8, 2018 [1, PDF p. 1]; [1, PDF p. 48]. Everything below is the nomination's account. The Alpena Evening News issues it quotes, and the Life-Saving Service and enrollment records it cites, were not read. Where the form disagrees with itself, both versions are given. Personal addresses, telephone numbers and email addresses that appear in the form and its letters are omitted.

A wooden freighter, and a storm

The site holds the remains of the three-masted, wooden-hulled bulk freighter JOSEPH S. FAY, wrecked "just offshore of Forty Mile Point Lighthouse" after a storm on 19 October 1905. Most wreckage, the summary says, "remains submerged in seventeen feet of water." A 134-foot starboard section is ashore [1, PDF p. 4].

The ship "was built in 1871" by Quayle and Martin of Cleveland for $80,000 and was commissioned by Alva Bradley for the Lake Superior iron ore trade. She was 215.6 feet long, 33.6 feet in beam, and 14.8 feet depth of hold, and 882.31 gross tons [1, PDF p. 5]. At launch, the nomination says, citing 1871 and 1872 newspapers, she was "the largest steamer that had ever been built in Cleveland" [1, PDF p. 5]. The same form also says "launching in 1872," gives a period "of 1872 (launch)," and refers to "1872 construction" [1, PDF p. 13]; [1, PDF p. 19].

Her original engine, a 28.5- by 36-inch machine from Cleveland's Cuyahoga Iron Works, was replaced in 1887 with a 24- by 44- by 30-inch steeple compound engine [1, PDF p. 5]; [1, PDF p. 17].

On Thursday, 19 October 1905, the Fay was steaming south toward Ashtabula, Ohio, with the consort barge D. P. RHODES in tow, both loaded with iron ore from Escanaba, when, the narrative says, "Furious east winds built quickly" to gale force and snow cut visibility [1, PDF p. 5].

What the wheelsman said, and what the form adds

Wheelsman George Rinley, quoted from the Alpena Evening News of October 23, 1905, said mate George Syze was washed overboard. The yawl left the ship "about 2:30 o'clock" with "only nine" aboard, "one of whom was the woman cook." The Fay was "leaking like a sieve." Rinley said the wind was "from the northeast," and that the crew "could gain no control of the vessel" and "were forced to let the ship go her course before the wind" [1, PDF pp. 5-6].

The next paragraph says "The ten crew eventually made land." The RHODES broke free and grounded at Cheboygan Point, and was later refloated. The Fay "sank on the sand bars directly offshore" of the lighthouse, and its starboard side was driven ashore "a distance of nearly eight-hundred feet." That same paragraph puts the remaining wreckage "in fifteen feet of water, perpendicular to the shore" [1, PDF p. 6]. An integrity passage says the crew "elected to run the vessel aground" [1, PDF p. 20]. The wind direction, the degree of control, the nine-versus-ten count, and the decision to beach the ship are left as the form gives them.

The site, and how it was nominated

The beached section measures 134 by 15 feet. Visitors have damaged timbers and removed iron fasteners. The sanctuary keeps a seasonal mooring buoy over the submerged part [1, PDF p. 9]. The form also locates the beached section "several hundred yards northwest" of the lighthouse, "several hundred yards up the beach," and "one-sixteenth-mile up the beach," and puts the submerged wreck one-quarter mile out [1, PDF p. 4]; [1, PDF p. 9]; [1, PDF p. 25]. A letter from the 40 Mile Point Lighthouse Society, dated February 7, 2017, in support of the nomination, says about 150 feet of the hull lies "200' west of the Lighthouse on the beach," with an additional section "northeast of the lighthouse approximately 100 yards from the beach" [1, PDF p. 49]. Depth is given as "seventeen feet," "fifteen feet," and "13-17 feet" [1, PDF p. 4]; [1, PDF p. 6]; [1, PDF p. 25]. A 2007 NOAA site plan in the nomination gives "DEPTH: 11-15 FEET" and wreck length 220 feet, beam 30 feet, against the registered 215.6 by 33.6 feet [1, PDF p. 32]; [1, PDF p. 5].

Fewer than five of the 100 known wreck sites in the 4,300-square-mile Thunder Bay National Marine Sanctuary, the nomination says, lie on land [1, PDF p. 20]. Significance is stated as statewide, under Criteria A, C and D, in Commerce, Engineering and Archaeology, with a period of significance 1871-1905 [1, PDF p. 1]; [1, PDF p. 12].

The Presque Isle County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously on Friday, January 27, 2017, to support the nomination, noting that the wreck "is located on the beach of the 40 Mile Point Lighthouse property owned by Presque Isle County" [1, PDF p. 50]. The National Park Service returned the first submission on or about November 27, 2017 (the comments are dated December 1, 2017) for a procedural error and two technical errors: the federal preservation officer had not signed, even though the site lies inside the sanctuary, and Criterion C and Archaeology had been omitted. The State Historic Preservation Office resubmitted the form on January 19, 2018, and the Park Service accepted it on February 8, 2018 [1, PDF pp. 83-86]; [1, PDF p. 48].

Single 2017-18 nomination; newspapers unread; internal conflicts shown; no personal contact data

Sources

  1. Hartmeyer, Philip A. “JOSEPH S FAY Shipwreck Site, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NPS Form 10-900).” National Register of Historic Places, prepared by Philip A. Hartmeyer; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (site number 20UH088, final reference RS100001838), prepared January 11, 2017, accepted February 8, 2018. Page references are PDF page numbers. In the final form (PDF 1-29), the printed "Section 8 page N" matches the PDF page. Registration form (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24 ↩25 ↩26 ↩27 ↩28 ↩29 ↩30

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.