The Upper Black River Drive Contract: Gainor v. Cheboygan River Boom Company (1891)
Scope
This entry follows one log-driving contract through the Michigan Supreme Court's 1891 decision in Gainor v. Cheboygan River Boom Company [1]. William Gainor sued the company "in the circuit court for Cheboygan county" [1, p. 113]. The contract, quoted in full in the opinion, describes both parties as of Cheboygan County [1, p. 114]. The report does not show that every part of the route lay in that county, and it does not locate the McDonald bridge on a modern map. Events are described as the court summarized the evidence, including where that evidence conflicted.
The agreement of March 27, 1888
The opinion reproduces a "memorandum of agreement" dated "this 27th day of March, A. D. 1888" [1, p. 114]. Gainor agreed to boom out of the Upper Black River, tow across Black Lake, and "run, drive, and deliver to below the McDonald bridge, in Lower Black river" all the saw logs the company had coming out of the upper river. He also agreed to carry logs from other points on the lake during the season of 1888 [1, p. 114]. He was to work "as fast as practicable," so that all logs would be delivered "as early in the summer of 1888 as the ordinary circumstances will admit." He was also to "promptly pick up and collect all logs which may go astray or be scattered on Black lake" [1, p. 115].
Pay was by the thousand feet, board measure. The rate was 9 cents for logs out of the Upper Black River, 10 cents from the Rainy River and the head of Black Lake, and 9 cents from all other points on the lake [1, p. 115]. The company would furnish booms and chains for towing. Progress payments were not to exceed 75 percent of the work estimated done, with final payment when the work was complete. The company did not have to receive logs faster than it could sort them at its sorting gap in the Lower Black River [1, p. 115].
How the work was done, and the first dispute
The court described the method. A "trip boom" at the mouth of the Upper Black River kept the logs from running out into the lake. Gainor placed a "bag boom" from the river mouth into the lake, opened the trip boom and ran logs out until the bag boom was full. The bag boom was then tied and towed across the lake to the head of the Lower Black River, while another waited at the river mouth [1, p. 116].
The parties disagreed about what "booming out" meant. Gainor said it meant swinging the bag boom, opening the trip boom and keeping men at the gap. The company said he also had to go up the river far enough to get the logs, and it claimed $524.70 for doing that work itself [1, pp. 116–117]. The meaning was left to the jury, which, the court said, evidently found for Gainor [1, p. 117].
The broken boom
It was admitted that about October 20, 1888, a boom of several hundred thousand feet of logs broke at the mouth of the upper river. "There was a conflict in the evidence as to who was responsible," the court wrote [1, p. 117]. The court also noted some evidence that company men had interfered with the boom, but said that point had not been raised at trial [1, p. 118].
Gainor did not gather the logs that fall. He claimed that Egbert Smith, the company's president, told him he could leave them in the lake until spring. Smith denied it. He said he had allowed only that Thompson Smith's Sons' logs could stay, and the rest too if the other owners consented. Gainor did not claim to have had their permission [1, p. 117]. The company said it began picking up logs on or about November 10, 1888, and recovered 270,000 feet at $1 per thousand. Gainor collected the rest in the spring [1, p. 117].
Outcome
The court pointed to the gap between that dollar and the contract's nine cents. It found no evidence that the company suffered any damage from the logs left until spring [1, p. 118]. The record showed that logs could be damaged "by pounding against the shore and filling with gravel." It did not show that the company received any less from the owners because of the delay [1, p. 118]. The company was "not entitled to receive any damages" for Gainor's failure to pick the logs up that fall [1, p. 120].
Gainor had claimed a balance of $686.84 and interest and recovered a judgment of $573.79 [1, p. 114]. The Supreme Court affirmed it, with costs [1, p. 121].
Related entries
Single source: this entry rests on one reported court decision. Events are described as the court summarized the evidence, including where that evidence conflicted.
Sources
- William Gainor v. The Cheboygan River Boom Company, 86 Mich. 112 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Morse, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 86, pp. 112–121, William D. Fuller, reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1891; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, decided May 15, 1891). Printed pp. 112–121 used (PDF pages 158–167 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.