Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Who Owned the Middle Ground? Fletcher v. Thunder Bay River Boom Company (1883)

Published · 1 cited source

County: Alpena County

Scope

This entry follows one lawsuit over land in the Thunder Bay River at Alpena, as the Michigan Supreme Court reported it in October 1883 [1]. The facts come from the court's summary of the trial record and from two agreements the reporter printed in footnotes. The report does not place the land on a modern map, describe what the boom company did there beyond a few words, or say what happened afterward. Some dates in the report conflict, and they are given as printed.

The claim

George N. Fletcher and Robert P. Toms brought ejectment against the Thunder Bay River Boom Company. They sought a piece of land "lying and being in Thunder Bay river, in front of lots 14 to 23, inclusive, in block 8, in the city of Alpena," described as part of "the middle ground" in the river [1, pp. 277–278]. They said an island or middle ground split the river into two channels there, and that the city lots on the west bank ran only to the center of the westerly channel [1, p. 278]. At trial in the Alpena circuit, the judge directed a verdict for the company [1, p. 278].

The court found that the easterly channel was the main channel. The westerly one, it said, was never used for navigation but "principally for floatage and giving access to a mill a little up the stream," and later by the company "for shore purposes and as booming water in common with others" [1, pp. 278–279]. The company owned lots 14 to 23 [1, p. 279].

Under water

The plaintiffs' testimony placed the stretch they claimed in front of lots 14 to 23 "nearly or quite under water all the time from two to five feet deep" [1, p. 279]. Two government surveys, dated February 12, 1841, and June 19, 1858, showed no middle ground or island there, and neither did the township survey or the city plat [1, p. 279]. On cross-examination Fletcher said: "This particular parcel of land that I am seeking to recover is land that is all under water to-day; it has not always been so." He added that the upper lots had at times been dry, "depending upon the rise and fall" of the river and the lake [1, p. 280].

The court said this evidence "might well be considered" to show there was no middle ground. It decided the case on title instead [1, p. 280].

The title

Fletcher, James K. Lockwood and John Oldfield had owned the government lots on both banks and platted the village of Alpena on them. The report dates that plat two ways: "June 28, 1857" on one page, and "the twenty-eighth day" of June 1859 on the next [1, pp. 279–280]. On April 8, 1865, Henry D. Bassett took a warranty deed, which the report describes as covering "village lots from 10 to 23 inclusive," though elsewhere it speaks of "these ten lots," 14 to 23, "without exception or reservation" [1, pp. 280–282]. He mortgaged them that year with the mill and buildings "built extending into the river." After foreclosure, the property was bid off on June 22, 1878, and sold to the company on March 22, 1880 [1, pp. 282–283].

Relying on its earlier decision in Watson v. Peters, the court held that a lot conveyed by a city plat and bounded on a navigable stream carries the land under the water to the center of the stream [1, p. 281]. The company's rights therefore ran "to the center of the main channel of the river," subject to the public easement [1, p. 284]. Even if there had been an island, it lay nearer the west shore and the government never "meandered" it in its survey, so it would pass with the west-shore lots [1, p. 283].

The private agreements

The owners had made agreements among themselves to divide the middle ground. The court called them "immaterial." It said they were made "long after" Bassett received his deed, and that any deed made under them, unless given to Bassett or his grantees, was "in fraud of Bassett's right" [1, pp. 284–286]. The dates in the report do not match. The court's text refers to "the agreement of June 8, 1868," but the reproduced agreement is dated "Alpena, June 8, 1860" [1, p. 284]. A second agreement, made in Detroit, is dated January 22, 1868 [1, pp. 284–285].

Justice Sherwood wrote the opinion, which affirmed the judgment with costs [1, pp. 277, 286]. Chief Justice Graves and Justice Cooley concurred. Justice Campbell concurred in the result only [1, p. 286].

Single source: one court opinion, which summarizes the trial record and reprints two agreements. Several dates in the report conflict and are given as printed.

Sources

  1. George N. Fletcher and Robert P. Toms v. The Thunder Bay River Boom Company, 51 Mich. 277 (Michigan Supreme Court, opinion of Sherwood, J.; Michigan Reports, vol. 51, pp. 277–286, Henry A. Chaney, state reporter, Chicago: Callaghan & Co., 1884; official scan hosted by the Michigan Courts, October Term 1883). Printed pp. 277–286 used (PDF pages 307–316 of the scan). Official scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.