Fourteen Superior Farmsteads: Land Types in Emmet County, 1939
Scope
This entry rests on one paper: Fred W. Foster, "Farmsteads and Land Types in Emmet County, Michigan," reprinted from Papers of the Michigan Academy of Science, Arts, and Letters, Vol. XXVII, 1941, published in 1942. The cover also describes it as a University of Michigan doctoral dissertation. Foster's affiliation at the end of the paper is Michigan State College, East Lansing [1, cover]; [1, p. 367]. The farmstead map is titled "Quality of Farmsteads 1939." This entry treats the work as a 1939 survey published in 1942. Numbers in Table I were read from the page scan, because the machine-read text garbles the table. Foster's judgments about which land could support a farm are his own argument, not independent facts. A promised later paper on abandoned farms was not located, and no abandonment counts are given here.
Land types and an older farm geography
J. O. Veatch set up the county's basic land types after reconnaissance in early summer 1937. The northern two-thirds were mapped that season, the work was completed in the summers of 1938 and 1939, and aerial photographs were used to refine it [1, p. 351].
"Indians were the first agriculturalists in Emmet County." Their fields were small, and some corn was sold at the Straits of Mackinac settlements. The fields stayed near Lake Michigan, so the well-drained lake-border types, Bliss, Readmond and Walloon, were "spotted with Indian clearings." Foster called reports of Indian orchards "Unverified" [1, p. 356].
In Emmet County, he wrote, lumbering and farming were "contemporaneous." Settlers piled and burned the trees they did not use for cabins and barns. Early farming rested on potatoes and root crops, grains, hay and cattle [1, p. 356].
Father Weikamp's mission farm "is supposed to have furnished" these 20-year average yields per acre: wheat 30 bushels, oats 60, rye 27, barley 26, potatoes 400, beets 400, carrots 400, turnips 500, rutabagas 500, and timothy hay 2½ tons [1, p. 357]. He does not give the farm's place or dates, and this entry does not add them.
From Walloon dairying to sand and clay
Farming on the Walloon (drumlin-like) land type was "the most successful in the county." It had specialized in dairying, most common near Petoskey; in certified seed potatoes; and in flowers sold to the resort market and in Chicago, with bulbs and seeds sold through seed firms [1, pp. 357-358].
On the Readmond, a dissected sandy moraine, slopes once farmed were "mostly abandoned today." Fields were often unfenced, natural hay led the hay crops, and soil humus had been "diminished through steady use" [1, p. 358]. Foster later noted "a great amount of abandonment" on the Readmond but gave no figures, and abandoned farms are excluded from his table [1, p. 366]; [1, p. 365].
On the Bliss type, "Through the efforts of George Gibes, a Polish immigrant," many Poles settled near Larks Lake. Their farms, Foster wrote, had neat buildings, diverse crops and "the ubiquitous geese" [1, p. 359].
The Brutus type was mostly occupied by Mennonites, who built "A prosperous farm community," and Foster also wrote that the area "is still successful." In the same paragraph he found "the evidences of agricultural decay are everywhere apparent." The heavy clay was hard to plow and stunted the corn [1, p. 359].
On the Pellston sand plain, farms appeared to function "below the level of subsistence," on stump pasture and natural hay. On the Cecil, farming was kept up to supply hay for lumber-camp horses. Farming was apparently never attempted on the Sturgeon dunes [1, pp. 359-360].
Part-time work off the farm came from second-growth timber, the cement plant, the highway department, resorts and winter factory jobs downstate. In 1939, Foster wrote, the average farm had seven cows of milking age, and about 3,400 acres were in potatoes, with stress on certified seed [1, p. 361].
Grading the farmsteads
Foster graded every occupied rural dwelling without first looking at its land type. He used five classes, from 1 (abandoned, reserved for the later paper) through 5 (superior), plus nonfarm dwellings. The scheme was adapted from a Cornell experiment-station bulletin [1, pp. 363-364].
Table I counts occupied farmsteads only. Walloon had 242 on 29.68 square miles, or 0.123 square miles each, with 21.5 percent in Class 2, 60.3 percent in Class 3, 15.7 percent in Class 4, and 6 superior. Readmond had 328 occupied farmsteads on 169.16 square miles; Bliss, 328 on 96.21; Cecil, 2 on 23.89 (11.94 square miles each). Sturgeon had none. Pellston had 18, of which 83 percent were inferior [1, p. 365]; [1, p. 367]. By this entry's arithmetic, the table sums to 1,197 occupied farmsteads and 14 superior ones, a total Foster's text also gives as "fourteen" [1, p. 366].
At least four of those 14 superior farmsteads were "supported by funds derived from outside sources." Foster ranked Walloon best, then McKinley and Brutus [1, p. 366]. He also argued that personal ambition, outside money and markets shape farmsteads, not land type alone [1, p. 351]; [1, p. 361]; [1, p. 366].
Single 1939 survey published in 1942; abandonment uncounted; Weikamp yields supposed
Sources
- Foster, Fred W. “Farmsteads and Land Types in Emmet County, Michigan.” reprinted from Papers of the Michigan Academy of Science, Arts, and Letters, Vol. XXVII, 1941, published 1942; Internet Archive scan, farmstead map titled Quality of Farmsteads 1939. Page references are the printed page numbers (pp. 351-367). Subtract 348 to reach the PDF page (printed p. 351 is PDF 3). Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22
Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.