Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

A Church From a Pattern Book: Elk Rapids First Methodist Episcopal Church

Published · 2 cited sources

County: Antrim County

Scope

This entry rests mainly on one document: the National Register of Historic Places registration form for the Elk Rapids First Methodist Episcopal Church, 301 Traverse Street, Elk Rapids, Antrim County [1, PDF p. 1]. Sally J. Weaver and Robert O. Christensen (Michigan SHPO) prepared it. The form lists the Elk Rapids Area Historical Society and the Michigan SHPO as the organization, and it is dated spring 2015 [1, PDF p. 16]. The National Park Service certification marks it as entered in the National Register, with a date of action of December 29, 2015 [1, PDF p. 1]. The form relies on county histories, a church memoir, a 1902 newspaper and other records that were not read for this entry, so their words appear here only as the form quotes them. Where the form gives two figures, both are given. The form describes the building as it was in 2015.

Before the building

The form says Methodism was the first denomination in Elk Rapids. The Rev. David R. Latham first visited on June 21, 1857, and organized a class there in July 1857 [1, PDF p. 8]. An earlier summary page in the same form puts his first visit in July 1857 [1, PDF p. 7]. The form quotes M. L. Leach's 1883 A History of the Grand Traverse Region, which called the class the "first church organization for white people on Grand Traverse bay" [1, PDF p. 8]; [1, PDF p. 13].

A church was formally organized as the First Methodist Episcopal Church of Elk Rapids during 1871 to 1874. In 1876 the congregation bought a former schoolhouse, "becoming the first religious organization in town to have their own church building," and dedicated it on May 18, 1876 [1, PDF p. 8]. By the early 1900s, when lumbering, iron smelting and cement making had brought the town's population to a peak of "around 1700," the congregation had outgrown its quarters [1, PDF p. 9].

Building it, 1901 to 1902

The church bought the site in August 1901 [1, PDF p. 9]. The form lists the warranty deed as Dexter & Noble Land Co. to the trustees, August 16, 1901 [1, PDF p. 14]. The cornerstone was laid on October 29, 1901, under the Rev. John W. Hart, and the building was dedicated on August 10, 1902 [1, PDF p. 9]. The form gives two costs. Its list of significant dates says "a cost of $8,250 for building and property" [1, PDF p. 6], while its narrative says the pastor "reported the cost of the building to be about $8500" [1, PDF p. 9].

A design by mail

The form calls the building "the embodiment of the Prices' Design No. 232," a design by Benjamin D. Price, an architect of Philadelphia and later New Jersey, and his son Max Charles Price. The design appears in their 1907 edition of Church Plans, at $30 for plans and specifications. That edition is later than the church. The form says the design "likely first appeared" in editions ten or more years earlier, which its preparers could not see [1, PDF p. 10]. According to the form, Price began supplying plans to the Methodist Episcopal Church's Board of Church Extension in 1876. By 1885 he had reportedly prepared sixty-seven designs for the board, which had sold 1975 sets of plans by mail [1, PDF p. 10]. The form estimates that Michigan churches built from Price designs number "certainly several dozen" [1, PDF p. 11]. Among the Michigan examples it lists, it says Elk Rapids follows Design 232 closely, "much more than nearly all the other Michigan examples listed above" [1, PDF p. 12].

Inside, it is an auditorium church. The floor slopes down toward the platform, and the oak pews were set in concentric arcs so that all of them faced it. Only one of the three sections of pews has been kept [1, PDF p. 5]. The form quotes the church architect George W. Kramer, whose 1897 book The What How and Why of Church Building said that "the seats should rise as they recede from the platform and will form concentric curves, every one facing the pulpit squarely." It concludes that "The Elk Rapids church embodies Kramer's recommendations" [1, PDF p. 9].

Yellow brick and colored glass

The walls are of locally made pale yellow brick, which the form compares to Milwaukee's "Cream City brick." It cites a personal history by Bess Wright Hoare, a member since 1899, as saying the brick came from a brickyard on her parents' farm and that her husband helped the masons [1, PDF p. 12].

Eight of the stained glass windows date from 1902. They show doves, fleur-de-lys, water lilies and other flower designs, crowns, crosses, bibles and oil lamps [1, PDF p. 4]. The form quotes the Elk Rapids Progress of June 26, 1902: "The windows on the East were furnished by the Kensaller Glass Co. of Chicago." No "Kensaller" firm has been identified, and the form says "it seems likely" the maker was the John J. Kinsella Glass Co. of Chicago. In the same passage it refers once to "nine 1902 windows," against eight everywhere else [1, PDF p. 12]. The five later windows date from 1948, 1949, 1952, 1977 and 1980 [1, PDF p. 4].

Later years

The form says the church was later retitled the First United Methodist Church. The United Methodist Church itself was created on April 23, 1968, when The Evangelical United Brethren Church and The Methodist Church "joined to form a new denomination" [2]. The form dates that merger to 1971 [1, PDF p. 9]. The congregation was discontinued in 2011, and the building was donated to the Elk Rapids Area Historical Society for its museum and archives [1, PDF p. 9].

Rests mainly on one National Register nomination. County histories, the Hoare memoir and the 1902 newspaper are quoted only as the form quotes them. Two cost figures and two first-visit dates given. The form's 1971 merger date is corrected from UMC.org (1968). The congregation's earlier quarters are not described.

Sources

  1. Weaver, Sally J., and Robert O. Christensen. “Elk Rapids First Methodist Episcopal Church, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NPS Form 10-900).” National Register of Historic Places, prepared by Sally J. Weaver and Robert O. Christensen; hosted by the National Park Service, NPGallery (NRIS 15000945), dated spring 2015, 36 pages. Page references are PDF page positions. Registration form (PDF) · NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24 ↩25 ↩26
  2. “When was The United Methodist Church created?.” Ask The UMC, United Methodist Communications, UMC.org, April 11, 2018 (read 2026-11-10). Web page · Archive status not checked ↩

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.