Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

The Dougherty Mission House at Old Mission

Published · 6 cited sources

County: Grand Traverse County

Scope

This entry describes a house at 18459 Mission Road in Peninsula Township, Grand Traverse County, through the records that describe it. They are of different kinds and weight. The listing facts come from the National Park Service and the Federal Register [1; 2]. The State of Michigan's historic sites record supplies the earlier state listing [3]. The main nineteenth-century account is M. L. Leach's History of the Grand Traverse Region, published in the Grand Traverse Herald in 1883 and written about forty years after the events [4]. The text of a 2016 state historical marker was read only in transcription [5]. The most detailed source is an unsigned draft National Register nomination dated October 20, 2010, prepared for the Peter Dougherty Society, which was then restoring the house [6, PDF pp. 7, 19]. The nomination as finally listed has not been digitized, so details found only in that draft are credited to it. This entry does not describe the house as it is today.

The listing

On March 17, 2011, the Federal Register listed "Dougherty Mission House, 18459 Mission Road, Peninsula, 11000176" under Grand Traverse County among nominations pending before the National Register [2]. The Park Service's record for reference number 11000176 gives a date of 4/8/2011. It lists "Dougherty, Rev. Peter" under significant names and gives 1842, 1861 and 1916 as significant years [1]. The state record shows an earlier step: "Dougherty Mission" was listed on the State Register on February 18, 1956. That record covers the house and a replica of Dougherty's 1839 mission building [3].

Dougherty and the mission

Leach writes that in May 1839 two Presbyterian missionaries, John Fleming and Peter Dougherty, came to Grand Traverse Bay to start a mission. They first built a log house at a site near the Elk River, where the village of Elk Rapids now stands. After Fleming left, Leach says, Ah-go-sa, the chief at Mission Harbor, offered to carry Dougherty and his goods across the bay and give him a house if he would live with his band. Dougherty accepted [4, pp. 8–9]. The marker text gives the same outline. It also says Dougherty had arrived at Mackinac in 1838 [5].

Building the house

According to Leach, "About 18[4]2," Dougherty began building "a more commodious dwelling" and a mission church. (The third digit of the year is damaged in the scan that was read.) The dwelling, "since known as the mission house," was in Leach's words "the first frame building erected in the Grand Traverse country." Forty years later, he wrote, it had been "enlarged and improved" and was occupied by "Mr. D. Rushmore" [4, p. 10]. The marker says Dougherty "and local Native Americans built this residence in 1842" [5]. The marker postdates the 2010 draft and may draw on it, so it does not independently settle the year. The state record calls the building "one of the first frame buildings" in Grand Traverse County, but gives a significant date of 1841 [3].

The 2010 draft adds details found nowhere else in these sources. It says Dougherty wrote in 1841 that a larger house was needed, and that building began in 1842 with help from Ahgosa's village. It quotes a diary entry of June 6, 1842, from the preparers' notes: "Began to raise the roof of the kitchen" [6, PDF p. 16]. It names Dougherty and George Johnston, carpenter, as builders [6, PDF p. 4]. Leach records a George Johnston at the mission as Indian carpenter by the fall of 1841 [4, p. 9]. The draft also says that Leach's "first frame building" claim "may be hard to prove definitively today," though it adds that "There seems to be no reason to doubt the statement's truth" [6, PDF p. 19].

Two sets of dates

The sources disagree on dates. Leach says Dougherty moved his mission to Mission Point, near Omena in Leelanau County, "early in the spring of 1852" [4, p. 11]. The marker also gives 1852 [5]. The 2010 draft gives both 1851 and 1852, and notes that "most sources agree" on 1852 [6, PDF pp. 4, 13, 17]. The draft also dates the founding of the mission to both 1839 and 1840 [6, PDF p. 13]. This entry does not choose between them.

The Rushmore years

The draft says the deed selling the property to Solon Rushmore is dated 1861, and that what happened to it between Dougherty's departure and that sale "is unclear" [6, PDF p. 17]. The marker says that after Solon's death in 1870 his cousin Duranty Rushmore bought the property. It says he was taking in tourists by 1876 (one transcription reads "in 1876"), and the house became known as the Rushmore House [5]. The draft cites a 1956 local history for a listing of the house as one of four hotels at Old Mission by 1881 [6, PDF p. 18]. Both the draft and the marker say the family sold the house to Virginia Larson in 1961 and that Peninsula Township acquired it in 2006 [5]; [6, PDF p. 19].

Sources of different weight: federal and state listing records, an 1883 county history, a marker text read in transcription, and an unsigned 2010 draft nomination. Details found only in the draft are attributed to it. Not a description of the house today.

Sources

  1. “Dougherty Mission House (NRIS 11000176).” National Park Service, NPGallery catalog record, undated catalog record. The linked nomination PDF reads “has not yet been digitized.” NPGallery record · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2
  2. “National Register of Historic Places; Notification of Pending Nominations and Related Actions.” National Park Service; Federal Register 76, no. 52, pp. 14686–14687 (FR Doc. 2011-6213), March 17, 2011. Full text · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2
  3. “Dougherty Mission (Site ID P23198).” State of Michigan, Michigan Historic Sites Online, undated web page; archived copy of March 2, 2014. Archived copy (March 2, 2014) · Live page no longer available ↩1 ↩2 ↩3
  4. Leach, M. L. “A History of the Grand Traverse Region.” Traverse City: published in the Grand Traverse Herald; Library of Congress copy, digitized by the Internet Archive, 1883. Printed pp. 8–11 used (PDF pages 16–19). Internet Archive copy · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
  5. “Dougherty Mission House / Rushmore House and Inn (marker S0739).” Michigan Historical Commission; text as transcribed in a marker-database export and by the Historical Marker Database, erected 2016; the physical marker and the state’s own marker record were not seen. HMdb transcription · Marker-database export (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6
  6. Cole, William L., Mary Ann Heidemann and Dennis Caviston. “Dougherty Mission House, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (NPS Form 10-900), unsigned draft.” Prepared for the Peter Dougherty Society; hosted on the Michigan State Historic Preservation Office’s blog, draft dated October 20, 2010. Page references are PDF page positions. Draft nomination (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.