Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

"This Practical Failure": Farming on Crawford County's Cut-Over Land, 1927

Published · 1 cited source

County: Crawford County

Scope

This entry rests on one report: Soil Survey of Crawford County, Michigan, Series 1927, No. 29, by J. O. Veatch, L. R. Schoenmann, Z. C. Foster and F. R. Lesh. It was published by the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Bureau of Chemistry and Soils with the Michigan Agricultural Experiment Station and the Michigan Department of Conservation [1, title page]. The survey describes the county as of 1927, with a few later figures from 1928 to 1930 [1, p. 3]; [1, p. 7]. The explanations of why farming did poorly are the surveyors' own judgments, and the report gives no farmers' own accounts. Numbers from the report's table were read from the page scan, because the machine-read text gets at least one of them wrong. This entry does not follow the land past the report.

Lumber first

The report ties the county's settlement to lumbering, "which began on a large scale in the decade 1870-1880." Most of the pine was gone by 1890 [1, p. 5]. Its summary says that "Settlement of the county began about 1870" [1, p. 37]. The early population "came primarily to operate the logging camps and lumber mills." The 1880 and 1890 censuses counted 175 and 202 farms, but the surveyors thought land actually in cultivation "probably did not exceed 3,000 acres." Farmers sold hay and feed to the camps and mills, and "the farmer could work in the logging camps in the winter and thus add to his income" [1, p. 5].

The county's permanent population never exceeded 5,000 [1, p. 5]. It stood at 4,049 in 1920 and was falling [1, p. 3]. Much of the land left behind was, in the report's words, "a desolation of charred tree stumps and trunks," or had grown up to aspen, oaks and red maple "with very little natural reproduction of the original dominant species" [1, p. 2].

"This practical failure"

The surveyors found only about 11 per cent of the county in farms and less than 3 per cent in cultivated crops or cleared for plowing. A footnote cites a Land Economic Survey estimate that 50 per cent of the farms or farm land was "abandoned farm land" [1, p. 5]. They wrote that "This practical failure of agricultural development may be accounted for in part by the rapidity with which the forest was exploited and failure to provide for reforestation." They added the "poor quality of most of the pineland" for the crops and methods then in use, the cost of clearing, the distance from outside markets, and the lack of local ones [1, p. 5].

"Probably the greater number of the earlier-established farms have been abandoned," the report adds, "particularly those on the more sandy lands" [1, p. 5].

The report's own figures for how much land was cleared do not agree. One passage says about 11 per cent of the cut-over forest land had been cleared at some time and about 2 per cent of the county was under cultivation [1, p. 2]. The summary says less than 5 per cent of the cut-over land was cleared for farming [1, p. 37]. Preliminary 1930 census figures put about 10 per cent of the county in farms [1, p. 7]. The report does not reconcile these numbers.

Where the farms held on

The surveyors tied success and failure closely to the soil. The county's four farming communities were "all located on the naturally most-productive soils," mostly loams. The dry sands, such as Grayling sand and Roselawn sand, were unused or very thinly settled and showed "the greatest number of abandoned farms and fields" [1, p. 7]. On Roselawn sand, cleared land had in places been "abandoned after a few years of hopeless farming" [1, p. 15]. On Grayling sand, "attempts made to cultivate the land have been attended with poor success" [1, p. 18].

The report's land classification puts the scale in view. On the page scan, its Class C, land "submarginal for farming or nonagricultural land under present conditions," covers about 333,000 acres, with less than 1 per cent cultivated and a "Large percentage of farms abandoned." Class A, the best farm land, covers about 4,000 acres [1, p. 8]. The whole county is 359,040 acres [1, p. 1]. Assessed values averaged $11.70 an acre for land in farms and $4.70 for wild or cut-over land [1, p. 8].

What farming remained was mainly hay, oats and potatoes, with dairying on the side. "Potatoes and milk are the chief sources of cash income" [1, p. 38].

The surveyors' advice

The report concluded that "a very large acreage of land in Crawford County is of little agricultural value." It was used only for "meager grazing" or for resort and recreation. It added that some of this land "may be utilized for the growing of timber by the State or National Government, at least until there is some real social or economic need for the land for homes and farms" [1, p. 8]. For Roselawn sand it named "forestry, game refuges, and hunting preserves" as the logical uses [1, p. 15]. The State already owned or controlled 74,845 acres, largely in forest reserves, plus a large tract in a State military reservation. Much of the rest was held by lumber companies, hunting and fishing clubs, and land companies holding it for speculation [1, p. 7]. These were the surveyors' recommendations in the late 1920s. This entry does not say what was done with them.

Single 1927 federal-state soil survey; explanations are the surveyors'. The report's clearing percentages do not agree. Nothing after the report.

Sources

  1. Veatch, J. O., L. R. Schoenmann, Z. C. Foster and F. R. Lesh. “Soil Survey of Crawford County, Michigan.” U.S. Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, Series 1927, No. 29; USDA National Agricultural Library collection, digitized by the Internet Archive, survey series 1927; printed by the U.S. Government Printing Office, 1931. Page references are printed page numbers; add 2 to reach the PDF page. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24 ↩25

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.