Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

Whitefish by the Million: The Fish Commission's Relief Station at Charlevoix, 1895-96

Published · 1 cited source

County: Charlevoix County

Scope

This entry rests on one source: the Twelfth Biennial Report of the State Board of Fish Commissioners, covering December 1, 1894, to December 1, 1896, and printed at Lansing in 1897 [1, title page]. The Internet Archive's catalog record dates the volume to 1884. That date is wrong; the scanned title page shows the 1894-96 biennium. The station report names only the town of Charlevoix, not the county. The county link comes from the report's planting tables, which are arranged by county: the 1895 brook trout table lists Stover's creek, in the township of Charlevoix, under the county heading "Charlevoix:" [1, p. 79], and the 1896 lake trout table lists plants "Off Charlevoix" in Lake Michigan under the same heading [1, p. 75]. The report does not say when the station was founded, and this entry does not follow the station past 1896.

A relief station

The Charlevoix station, under its overseer J. P. Marks, was "still run as a relief station for the hatching of eyed whitefish ova" [1, PDF p. 68]. Whitefish eggs first developed at the Detroit hatchery. The share meant for Lake Michigan and the Straits of Mackinaw was then sent to Charlevoix, where the hatching was completed [1, PDF p. 68]. "The building occupied at this place is rented," the report says. It had been fitted up at small cost, was run by one regular employee of the Board, and had received no improvements during the biennium beyond small repairs [1, PDF p. 68].

The report says the station "is only run for about two and a half or three months of the year" [1, PDF p. 68]. Its own water-temperature records for the "Charlevoix Relief Station" run from February 17 to April 25, 1895, and then from November 15, 1895, to April 28, 1896, a stretch of more than five months. Readings ranged from 32 to 44 degrees [1, p. 114]. The report does not explain the difference.

Millions of fry

The planting tables show the scale. Whitefish plants "from Charlevoix House" in 1895 totaled 32,000,000, all made between April 6 and April 25 [1, p. 70]. Plants "from Charlevoix Station" in 1896 totaled 29,461,400, made between April 7 and April 28. The report's total for all whitefish plants that year was 121,681,400 [1, p. 72].

The places listed include Charlevoix itself, Pine Lake, Norwood, Fisherman's Island, Beaver Harbor, Fox Island, Cat Head Point, Little Traverse Bay, Middle Village, Cross Village, Crystal Lake, Manistee and Old Mission Point on "Big Traverse bay" [1, p. 70]; [1, p. 72]. The tables do not give counties for these places. Not every plant was made off Charlevoix itself.

The 1896 lake trout table, arranged by county, lists three plants of 250,000 lake trout each "Off Charlevoix" in Lake Michigan, made by the Michigan Fish Commission on April 1, 3 and 7 [1, p. 75]. The table does not say where those trout were hatched.

The wreck at Traverse City

The station also eased the work of the Board's fish car, the Attikumaig, whose captain was H. H. Marks [1, PDF p. 69]. After an overhaul costing about $1,400, the car's first trip was a run to Charlevoix carrying 21,000,000 whitefish eggs. It was "thrown from the track by the misplacing of a switch at Traverse City," and all the cargo was lost. The report held the C. & W. M. Ry. responsible [1, PDF p. 69]. The car report dates the overhaul only to "a year ago last fall." The Detroit hatchery's account of the 1895-96 season adds that the 600 quarts of eggs "shipped November 25th to Charlevoix were all lost through the wrecking of the fish car near Traverse City" [1, p. 30], which places the wreck in late November 1895.

A hatchery for lake trout

The report wanted more at Charlevoix. The station report calls it "the most important point for the taking of lake trout in the State" and recommends a permanent lake trout hatchery there, if the municipality would grant "a free site and a perpetual water supply" [1, PDF p. 68]. In its own section, the Board says Charlevoix "is the center of the best salmon trout grounds on the lake system" and estimates that buildings and equipment "will not exceed five thousand dollars" [1, p. 22]. Whether such a hatchery was ever built lies outside this report and was not checked.

Single 1897 Fish Commission biennial report. The station report names only the town; the county link comes from the planting tables on pp. 75 and 79. The report does not say when the station was founded, and the entry does not follow the station past 1896.

Sources

  1. “Twelfth Biennial Report of the State Board of Fish Commissioners from Dec. 1, 1894, to Dec. 1, 1896.” State Board of Fish Commissioners (Michigan); Lansing: Robert Smith Printing Co., State Printers and Binders; University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign copy at the Internet Archive, 1897. The Internet Archive catalog date 1884 is wrong; the scanned title page shows the 1894-96 biennium. Page references are printed page numbers. Printed p. 22 is PDF 38 and printed p. 30 is PDF 46; for pp. 70-114 add 22. The Charlevoix station and car reports carry no printed page number and are cited by PDF page. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.