Northern Knowledge Library

A small, cited encyclopedia of northern Michigan local history and farm knowledge

High Water on the Alcona Shore, 1972-74

Published · 1 cited source

County: Alcona County

Scope

This entry rests on one report: Appendix III of the Great Lakes Shoreline Damage Survey, prepared for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers by the University of Michigan's Coastal Zone Laboratory [1, title page]. Its title page is dated November 1975; the Internet Archive's record for this DTIC scan gives 1976. The residential figures come from owners' answers to a "Self-Administered Assessment" and from interviews [1, p. 1], and the park figures from one ranger [1, p. 17]; [1, p. 51]. They are reported values, not engineering measurements. The report's statistical tables were not read, so no per-reach dollar figures appear here.

The report is a joint State of Michigan and Corps pilot study of damage in six counties "caused by or directly related to the 1972-74 high water period on the Great Lakes." Lake levels had hit a record low in 1965. From 1972 they stood at levels comparable to 1951-52, the period of an earlier Corps damage study [1, p. 3].

The shore

Alcona County's Lake Huron border "is 27 miles long," generally erodible plain with some high bluff between Greenbush and Harrisville. North of Harrisville the shore is mainly "stone and boulder"; to the south the beaches are mostly sand [1, p. 7]. Three high-risk erosion areas totaled "about three miles" [1, p. 8]. The surveyors split it into three reaches, numbered from the Iosco County line north. In Reach 2, which reference material called lowland, field inspection "revealed stretches of high bluff" [1, p. 12].

Who used it

Residential use made up 97 percent of lakeshore properties, commercial or industrial use 1 percent, and government land 2 percent [1, p. 17]. The coast consisted mainly of resort towns; one of the largest, Harrisville, had 487 people [1, p. 8]. Homes were "primarily used on a seasonal basis only," and in the north 88 percent of respondents used their property seasonally. Assessed values ran from $132 per foot of frontage in Reach 3 to $240 in Reach 1 [1, p. 17].

Damage and defenses

Reach 1 reported the most flood damage; the bluffs of Reach 2 "offer more protection" [1, p. 36]. Owners reported moderate erosion losses. Of the county's 121 dwellings, 99 stood within 50 feet of the bluff in Reach 1 [1, p. 39]. Non-residential owners reported $45,000 in erosion damage and the loss of "9,000 cubic yards of sand" [1, p. 43].

The only permanent shore protection the survey identified was a publicly owned revetment-seawall "just south of the Harrisville Harbor." It was about 200 feet long and six to eight feet high, made of broken concrete and rock that appeared "randomly placed." Private seawalls, revetments and steel-piling groins were classed as expedient, of "limited effectiveness" [1, p. 29]. A preliminary study at Harrisville Harbor had so far produced results that "do not attribute the erosion to the harbor" [1, p. 58].

Harrisville State Park

A park ranger supplied the park's account because there were "no official reports" [1, p. 51]; [1, p. 52]. Erosion damage was "slight," but the park lost about 12 cedars and two or three ash trees, and 40 to 50 feet of beach along a quarter-mile stretch, "1 1/3 acres of beach lost" in all. In August 1974, waves washed over two or three low-lying campsites during a storm [1, p. 52].

Attendance fell from 123,747 in 1971 to 102,873 in 1972 and 104,803 in 1973, then rose to 120,110 in 1974. The report attributes the dip to a new counting method, a cool spring in 1973 and the gas shortage, and says the 1974 rise "is correlated with the salmon fishing in the fall" [1, p. 52].

The county summary

The summary gives reported flood damage of $110,000 and reported erosion damage of $397,000. It also gives "expanded" values, which the report says were calculated "to indicate the extent of damages incurred over the entire population," because the owner assessment covered only 60 to 80 percent of it [1, p. 63]: $644,000 for flood and erosion damage and $293,000 for owners' protective costs. None of the reaches was designated an area of major damage. The calculated beach loss was "only one million square feet," and the bluff loss 16 million cubic feet [1, p. 66]. Earlier, the report calls the eroded bluff volume "minimal in comparison with other areas" [1, p. 39].

The summary also lists wetlands as a major shoreform, though the wildlife section says the county "does not possess any wetland areas which would be influenced by higher lake levels" [1, p. 61]. The report does not reconcile the two.

Single 1975 Corps/University of Michigan Coastal Zone Laboratory survey (Appendix III). Residential figures are owner-reported; park figures come from one ranger. The statistical tables were not read, so no per-reach dollar figures appear. The report does not reconcile its two wetland statements.

Sources

  1. Armstrong, John M., Michael R. McGill, Andrew M. Kubek, Carolyn K. Barber and Jacques F. Gillette. “Appendix III, Great Lakes Shoreline Damage Survey: Muskegon, Manistee, Schoolcraft, Chippewa, Alcona, and Huron Counties, Michigan (1 of 2).” Coastal Zone Laboratory, The University of Michigan, prepared for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, North Central Division, Chicago, Contract No. DACW23-75-C-0027; DTIC AD-A031 456; Internet Archive scan, title page dated November 1975; Internet Archive catalog date 1976. Page references are printed page numbers. Add 7 to reach the PDF page. Internet Archive scan (PDF) · Archive status not checked ↩1 ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24

Compiled with AI assistance from the cited sources and checked claim by claim against them. Images, where shown, are credited in their captions. Spotted an error? See corrections.